I wrote the first three posts in an attempt to straighten out some of my own views and I thought long and hard before sharing them. I was intimidated, perhaps; not so much by the currently politically correct suspicion that no white man has the right to opine on race – though that never seems to stop demented pundits and their followers from, for example, squarely placing the blame for police brutality against the black population on… the black population.
Much more important to me than the fundamentally chickenshit vagaries of PC is the question of spouting off about a subject of which I can have no deep emotional understanding because I’m a white man in a white man’s society.
With these misgivings in mind, I ran the material by friends – writers, producers and entrepreneurs of one sort or another. People I respect. I have collated their responses and present them as if they are once voice:
It’s interesting that, as we’ve discussed, the U.K. is de facto more integrated than the U.S.; an apparently higher level of intermarriage, to the extent that in London and other big cities, interracial couples are so common as to be totally unremarkable. Also, there is nothing like the residential segregation here that’s the norm in the U.S.
Americans by and large don’t seem to acknowledge (or know?) that U.S. Blacks have punched way, way above their weight in their contribution to international culture. Taking music alone: the huge breadth and depth, worldwide, of popular music – which effectively is Black music; everything from jazz (New Orleans, mainstream, big band, bop) blues, rhythm’n’blues, rock’n’roll, soul, swing, zydeco, etc. etc. Black American music has become the popular music of the world, from Beyonce to Khelani – and the deracinated R’n’B that is the lingua franca of pop is just Black music without Blacks. What has the U.S. white lower and lower middle class (the most racist bloc) contributed? Country music, 80 per cent of which is crap, and which anyway doesn’t mean shit outside the U.S. This is before we consider the contribution of Black comedians, writers, actors etc. What’s also amazing is that US Blacks, bearing in mind they’re outnumbered about 8 to 1, have survived at all, let alone made such a contribution.
I read somewhere whereby working class people striving towards the middle class, unless they have access to the cultural norms of middle class life – very broadly, books, theatre, cinema, art etc. – just become rich working class people. You have the phenomenon of university students who are ignoramuses, educated know-nothings data-stuffed but with zero ability to analyze or put their knowledge into any kind of moral or humane context.
One of the many things about which white people know more or less zero is Black history whether it’s Windrush in the UK, King Leopold in the Congo, Zulu and Matabele uprisings against the British, and, particularly, the narrative of Black Americans: slavery, Jim Crow, Frederick Douglas, MLK, Charles Wright, James Baldwin, Tommie Smith, Robert Johnson, Muddy Waters… the list is endless.
Not one of the commentators I talked to was sure what all this means. Perhaps, we seem – the human race – increasingly to be embracing ignorance as a virtue; and excoriating education, science and the humanities as works of Satan. And the more widespread ignorance is, the less chance there is of understanding the ‘other’.
And let’s not even consider fundamental religionism…

Quite what authentic blues are, I’m not sure. Robert Johnson, certainly, but there are people who will tell you that once Muddy Waters invented electricity, he surrendered his authenticity. Most of those aficionados will be white and on the earnest side because blues, like jazz, does not have much of a Black following. Perhaps that’s why Little Jimmie’s band was all white, the drummer looking as though he’d be more at home in a country western setting; the harmonica lank haired and ineffably sad of expression; the bass player young, tubby, curly haired and apparently in charge of the play list. The set up reminded me of a Chuck Berry tour. One of the three or four fathers of rock, Chuck traveled solo and picked up usually white musicians at his various venues.
It’s easy to miss –
A few days earlier, I’d been in another club, the band playing extreme up-tempo versions of Bob Marley classics and its singer much more concerned with engaging – chivvying – her audience than actually singing. It was so irritating that I left.
